This Unit Activity will help you meet these educational goals: 21st Century Skills—You will use critical-thinking and problem-solving skills and communicate effectively.
Introduction
In this activity, you will read and analyze three poems by different poets and examine the similarities and differences among them. __________________________________________________________________________
Directions and Analysis
Task 1: Read and Analyze Poetry
Read these poems, which revolve around the ideas of darkness and the night: “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” by Dylan Thomas
“Acquainted with the Night” by Robert Frost
“We Grow Accustomed to the Dark” by Emily Dickinson
Read the poems a few times, noting each one’s theme, mood, form, structure, rhyme scheme, and use of imagery and figurative language. Use the provided table to record your analysis.
Type your response here:
“Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night”
“Acquainted with the Night”
“We Grow Accustomed to the Dark”
theme
Mortality
Isolation
To “find the light”
imagery
Sunrise and sunset
Loneliness
figurative language
Their frail deeds might have danced in a green bay
Personification and rhyming
Darkness and light
mood
Somber desperation
Discomfort
Sadness
form
Villanelle
The Essay on What Whitman Walt Read Poems
... entertaining and make the reader want to read the poem. The above poem is telling of the experience of sailing ... foam of day, or under many a star at night, By sailors young and old haply will I, ... dad was an English carpenter who probably could not read his sons poetry. His parents family consisted of ... slavery which in turn helped him write his poems according to Walt Whitman. Between 1848 and 1855 ...
Iambic pentameter
Lyric poem
meter, structure, and rhyme scheme
five three-line stanzas and a sixth stanza with four lines
Terza rima, ABABCBCDCDADAA, Italian form
Rhythm is similar throughout, but changes from eight and six syllable lines to seven and six syllables to seven and six syllables.
Task 2: Make Comparisons
Write a 250-500-word essay describing the similarities and differences you found in the poems. Address the following points in your essay: Examine how the subject of darkness is used in each of the three poems. How has each poet woven the central idea of the poem around the subject? Compare and contrast the figurative devices used in each poem. How do they affect the mood and relate to the theme of the poem? Point out the differences in style and tone, including the choice of words. Which poem do you think has the greatest overall impact on readers? Which one communicates its message most directly and effectively? Which poem appeals most to you? Give reasons to explain your answers.
As with any essay, this essay should be structured into paragraphs, with a clear introduction, a body, and a conclusion. Arrange your ideas logically and group them into paragraphs, using suitable words to mark transitions between ideas. Remember to provide textual evidence from the poems for your
opinions.
Type your response here:
The similar ideas of dark and night appear in works by Emily Dickinson, Dylan Thomas, and Robert Frost, but the meaning of the two concepts in context of the literary works differ greatly. In Emily Dickinson’s “We Grow Accustomed to the Dark”, Dylan Thomas’ “Do Not Go Gentle into that Good Night”, and Robert Frost’s “Acquainted with the Night” the theme of night and darkness is compared and contrasted through the literary elements of point of view, imagery, and structure. The concept of darkness and night is portrayed through the use of point of view. In each of these poems, the poet writes in the first tense, giving the reader a sense that the narrator has personally experienced the presence of the symbolic “darkness” and “night”.
The Term Paper on Critical Appreciation Of The Poem ‘Ode To The West Wind‘
“Thunder is good; thunder is impressive. But it is lightening that does the work.” The poem ‘’Ode to the West Wind’’ was written in the autumn of 1819, in the beautiful Cascine Gardens outside Florence and was published with ‘‘Prometheus Unbound’’ in 1820. The poet is himself in a mood of despondency and misery and says that he falls upon the thorns of life and is bleeding. He is seeking ...
However, while “We Grow Accustomed to the Dark” is written in a plural point of view, “Acquainted with the Night” is written in a singular view, and “Do Not Go Gentle into that Good Night” is from the speaker point of view. This gives a differing meaning to dark and night between these poems, because although Dickinson’s plural poem encompasses humanity as a whole, showing the dark to be a natural point in life, Frost’s poem depicts the night his character is experiencing as a lonely, solitary happening, and Thomas’ poem shows loneliness and wanting for companionship. The differences in these poems help to show night as a more unnatural and depressing experience than the dark that happens to everyone.
__________________________________________________________________________ Evaluation
Your teacher will use these rubrics to evaluate the completeness of your work as well as the clarity of thinking you exhibit.
Task 1: Read and Analyze Poetry
Criteria
Distinguished
(4 points)
Provides a complete and accurate analysis of each poem
Exhaustively lists instances of figurative language and use of imagery
Provides a concise but compelling description of the mood and theme of each poem
Proficient
(3 points)
Provides a complete and largely correct analysis of each poem
Lists most instances of figurative language and use of imagery
Provides an effective description of the mood and theme of each poem
Developing
(2 points)
Provides a complete analysis of the poems with some inaccuracies
Lists some instances of figurative language and use of imagery
Provides a passable description of the mood and theme of each poem
Beginning
(1 point)
Provides an incomplete analysis of the poems with some inaccuracies
Lists only a few instances of figurative language and use of imagery Attempts to describe the mood and theme of the poems
Task 2: Make Comparisons
Criteria
Distinguished
(4 points)
Thoroughly addresses all the points mentioned
The Essay on Compare And Contrast Of Goldsm
Compare and Contrast of Goldsm Sarah Ajdarodini Dr. Shipmann Eng. 261 December 14, 2000 Compare and Contrast of Goldsmiths The Deserted Village and Crabbes The Village The Deserted Village by Oliver Goldsmith (O.G.) and The Village by George Crabbe (G.C.) are two remarkable poems of the eighteenth century. Both of the poems are similar and different in many ways. The theme of The Deserted Village ...
Effectively compares how the subject has been woven into the central idea in the three poems
Thoroughly evaluates and compares the effect of figurative language and imagery in the poems
Insightfully compares the style and impact of the poems
Provides strong textual evidence to support opinions
Structures the essay exceptionally well, has a compelling introduction and conclusion, and uses transitions to enhance the organization of ideas Consistently uses correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation throughout
Proficient
(3 points)
Adequately addresses most of the points mentioned
Effectively compares how the subject has been woven into the central idea in the three poems
Adequately evaluates and compares the effect of figurative language and imagery in the poems
Effectively compares the style and impact of the poems
Provides adequate textual evidence to support opinions
Structures the essay well, has a meaningful introduction and conclusion, and uses transitions effectively
Largely uses correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation
Developing
(2 points)
Adequately addresses some of the points mentioned
Compares how the subject has been woven into the central idea in the three poems
Evaluates and compares the effect of figurative language and imagery in the poems to some extent
Compares the style and impact of the poems
Provides some textual evidence to support opinions
Structures the essay into paragraphs, has an introduction and a conclusion, and uses transition words
Makes a few mistakes in grammar, spelling, and punctuation
Beginning
(1 point)
Marginally addresses some of the points mentioned and omits others
Attempts to compare how the subject has been woven into the central idea in the three poems
Inadequately describes the effect of figurative language and imagery in the poems
Attempts to compare the style and impact of the poems
Does not provide textual evidence to support opinions
Does not structure the essay well and does not use transitions effectively
Makes several mistakes in grammar, spelling, and punctuation
