Goodman Brown, from “Young Goodman Brown” and Hooper, from “The Minister’s Black Veil” are two characters that suffer from a pride of intellect. Their pride causes them similar problems and they end up living similar lives, although they came from different backgrounds. Hooper and Goodman Brown both become isolated from society. Hooper had a revelation, and he feels that he truly understands human nature and sin. However, he believes that he is above everybody else because he has this understanding. This is what causes the major separation between Hooper and society. After Hooper dawns the veil he can no longer function or act as a normal person, because of this feeling of superiority.
His perception of an ultimate human isolation leaves him the man most isolated in what Hawthorne describes as that saddest of all prisons, his own heart . . . “(The Minister’s Black Veil,228).
The veil affects all parts of his life, his fiance leaves him and he can no longer relate to his congregation the same way. “As a result of wearing the veil, Hooper becomes a man apart, isolated from love and sympathy, suspected and even feared by his congregation”(Minister’s Black Veil, 228).
Goodman Brown suffers the same fate because he also has a feeling of superiority over the rest of the village. He attains this feeling after he sees all the people that he though were good and pure participating in satanic rituals in the forest. He looses all faith in the community and feels as though he is above them because he was able to resist the devil. The lack or trust trusting that Goodman Brown had separated him from the community because he was a strong Puritan and felt as though he could not associate devil worshipers. “Brown, despairing and embittered, belongs neither to the Devil’s party nor to the only other life-sustaining cause he knows–that of the Puritan faith and the Puritan community”(Levy,119).
The Essay on A Comparison Of "Young Goodman Brown" And “A Goodman Is Hard To Find”
True evil is more than an emotion or an act; it is an existence that encompasses ones complete being. Many authors try to depict evil but never capture the full essence of it. The stories of “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne and “A Goodman is Hard to Find”� by Flannery O’ Connor clearly illustrate pure evil. Contained in both stories is an issue where evil ...
Hooper and Goodman Brown’s pride of intellect cause them to loose a loved one and their kind and loving nature.
Hooper drives his fiance Elizabeth away by wearing the veil. Elizabeth sees how Hooper is separating himself and it scares her away from their purposed marriage. “Hooper’s fiancee, seems at first unawed by the veil. To her it is merely a cloth that hides the face she most delights to see. But, like a sudden twilight in the air, Elizabeth suddenly senses the unapproachable inner isolation of the man who wears it, and its’ terrors fall upon her, too”(The Minister’s Black Veil,228).
As a result of Hooper pride, he looses his loving and kind nature. “Hooper is shunned and even feared by the others in their times of health and happiness”(The Minister’s Black Veil,228).
He concentrates so much on the negative aspects of people that he refuses to see the good in them. “He makes the dark side of people the whole truth of human existence. His own kind and loving nature is lost for all”(The Minister’s Black Veil,228).
Goodman Brown also looses someone very close to him. He separates himself from his wife Faith. This is a result of Goodman Brown’s pride.
He felt so strongly that he was the only innocent person that he could not trust anybody else including Faith, his apparently religiously devote wife. When Goodman Brown saw Faith in the forest (Hawthorne, 178) she became just like the other townsman. “He now knows that Faith’s voice has been mingled with the other familiar tones, heard daily at Salem village”(Levy,118).
The Essay on The Ministers Black Veil Verses Goodman Brown
The Veil of the Minister and Goodman Brown Nathaniel Hawthornes short stories The Ministers Black Veil and Young Goodman Brown are two stories that are thick with allegory. Young Goodman Brown is a moral story which is told through the perversion of a common townsperson. In Young Goodman Brown, Goodman Brown is a Puritan who lets his excessive pride in himself interfere with his relations with the ...
Goodman Brown’s loving nature is also lost due to his pride. He becomes separates himself so much that he can no longer hold a loving relationship with Faith like he did early in the story(Hawthorne,165).
Hooper from “The Minister’s Black Veil” and Goodman Brown from “Young Goodman Brown” both suffer similar fates from their pride of intellect.
It caused them to be drastically separated from society, and to loose loved ones and their loving nature. Their pride of intellect changed their whole lives. It can be seen as a cloak that the characters try to wrap themselves in to escape human nature and mankind. It is obvious that the characters did not consider or were not aware of the penalties of their intellectual pride.
