There is no doubt that challenging or difficult situations can reveal the best or worst characteristics in individuals. These similarities and differences of overwhelming personal adversity in Animal Farm by George Orwell and The Giver by Lois Lowry will be discussed. Napoleon does not enjoy the idea of having a democratic government so he chooses to exile snowball to start a dictatorship. The selfishness in napoleon’s leadership is contrasted to the hardship that Jonas must face when refusing to submit to the dictator’s figure of the Giver. The right has been given to Jonas to receive memories before “sameness”, which is very similar to the role that Napoleon plays in the communist community of the pigs after the death of Old Major. In substance the compare and contrast of the vivid personal adversity will be gone over in these two major novels.
In Animal Farm, the plot goes around the victory of Old Major and the overthrow of Mr.Jones leading to the full overtaking of the farm. After this overthrow Snowball and Napoleon are put in charge over the pigs with the motto “all pigs are equal.” However during this leadership Snowball is run off the farm by Napoleon’s taste for power starting a dictatorship. Therefore takes control of all the animals of the farm. Boxer who had thought about what Napoleon had did spoke his mind saying” if comrade Napoleon says it, it must be right.” From there he adopted the saying “Napoleon is always right” this shows how Napoleon has failed to keep the oath he had made to Old Major, and now is running a communist regime. This shows how Napoleons idea of equality had completely diminished creating alliance with the humans.
The Essay on Animal Farm Napoleon Snowball Animals 2
... field the neighboring farms came to the farm and the animals had been expecting this so Snowball lead the charge while Napoleon and squealer hid ... meetings and no more debates and that a committee of pigs would make all the decisions. Soon he proclaimed that the ... causing Old Major to fall out of the hay loft and break his neck. Later Napoleon and Snowball come to prepare the animals for ...
Also in The Giver, Jonas a young boy who has been given the privilege of receiving the memories of the giver before the time of “sameness.” This novel takes place in a communist dystopia, which reflects the unique gift of receiving memories before people were taught to act “the same” in this type of society. However, Jonas quickly learns that the giver is really against freedom and individualism that distorts knowledge and disperses it to the slave population. Jonas rebels against the giver and runs away to the land of elsewhere. The giver try’s to warn Jonas into staying to keep the memories of individualism and liberty for the community: “if you get away, if you get beyond, if you get to elsewhere, it will mean that the community has to bear the burden of themselves, of the memories you had been holding for them.” This makes Jonas question running away but he understands he needs to free himself to find elsewhere. The Giver using its knowledge to exploit the people Jonas has no choice but to escape. This shows how Jonas had to struggle for individualism and identity in this novel.
The similarities between Napoleon and Jonas are drawn out through the rejection of communism in a once free society. The Giver and Old Major are great examples of individual’s that seek to keep all “equal” in society, but Napoleon and Jonas are against these ideals as a way to clear up the issue of replication and strict attitude towards principals. However Napoleon does become a solo dictator, which contrasts Jonas singular choice to free himself from the shackles of communist society. On multiple occasions Napoleon goes on killing sprees if the other animals do not do exactly what he says. On the other hand Jonas sees that the Giver will aid his escape to elsewhere, he soon makes the trip with the memories or strength and courage. Jonas is an example of the contrasting hardship, with flips Napoleons selfish individualism into Jonas’ selfless individualism that save the baby and escape to elsewhere. These are the major similarities and differences to personal hardship in these novels.
The Essay on Napoleon and Modern Society
Benjamin Franklin once said “They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. ” I could not agree more with this quote. There have been so many countries that have fought for their freedom, including the U. S. and France, but the question is how quickly these countries would be able to sacrifice those hard fought liberties for their safety. When ...
In conclusion, a comparison and contrast analysis to the challenge of personal hardship has been studied through the characters Napoleon and Jonas. In the character of Napoleon, rejection of his attempt of a communist society resulted in major conflict with Snowball leading him to run a cruel communist regime over the farm. In contrast to this form of hardship, Jonas realizes the monocracy of the givers memories, which forces him to flee to elsewhere in hope of saving the newborn child and for saving his freedom. However, Napoleon and Jonas are quite similar in the way they react to the boundaries to individualism in a communist society. These are the important aspects to react against personal hardship that is in these two great novels. penis
