There is a difference in attitudes in men towards war, specially when one goes to war volunteering out patriotism, or if you go to war simply because you were drafted. Therefore leaving behind things and goals, you had in mind, instead of combat. Both stories relate to post war nostalgia, In O’Brien’s is about a middle age veteran twenty years after Vietnam, still having nightmares about the era. This story tells us about two friends, Bob Kiley and Curt Lemon, two young kids in their late teens, in addition, it talks about the horrors of war. Curt Lemon was characterized by valor, courage and I can do attitude He liked to volunteer for dangerous missions such as night patrols, and doing reckon, but it clearly states that this was done out the thrill of the challenge.
Nothing states this was done because of the love of his country. In addition, he describes these kids as just being there without any sense of what was really happening around them. They did not understand about the horror of war the reality of the situation. As far as they were concern this was just another camping trip out in the woods, and acted just like it by evidence they played games with grenades, true they were smoke grenades, nevertheless this were tools of a war. On the other hand, Bob Kiley was characterized by the profound love and admiration of his pal Curt Lemon and how much was he affected by his death. It tell us about the letter he send his sister after his death and how two months later she does not reply, this was if nothing else and attempted by Kiley to get closure.
The Essay on Commentary How to Tell True War Story
... mentions Rat Kiley as the helpful medic for the dying friend. “Dentist” follows as a goodbye story to Curt Lemon. O’Brien includes ... the heartbreaking story before O’Brien switches gears, saying, “A true war story is never moral” (68). He sets qualifications for ... random, is actually predetermined. The core theme that a true war story cannot be factually believed is repeated multiple times ...
Later in the story it revels how Bob Kiley still frustrated by the death of his friend, simply start shooting the baby buffalo. He shoots the animal little by little almost as enjoying seeing the animal agonized. The comments after that massacre were ” Well that’s Nam”Garden of Evil.” War is full of surprises and only people that have been there can really know about a true war story Mr. O’Brien conveys thorough the story. War is uncertain that is a fact of war no matter how much a sense of patriotism a soldier has whatever they do does it still right.
Soldiers are asked to kill other human beings, a deed punished by law. Does it make it right? Perhaps only whatever goes to the mind of those soldiers in battle can give us the answer. In, a Soldier’s Home, Ernest Hemingway places us after the war as well. It tells us about a younger, veteran of post war world I Harold Krebs. That comes back home ten years after the war has ended.
When he comes back home there is no more heroes’ welcome. Instead he find that all the soldiers that returned ten years ago when the war ended, had already found a place in the community. That’s not the case for Harold for he change in the past years, instead he spend most of his energy just killing time, by playing pool, practicing on his clarinet, or just strolling downtown. He cannot no longer adjust to living there anymore he cannot not even talk to girls anymore a waste of time he says.
The problem relies on what Krebs use to do before going to war he was a young students that attended religious school. Live a middle class life and all the shelter this provides then he enlists in the marine’s note it says enlist and not drafted. This shows he had sense of patriotism at the time. However, later in the story it let us knows that Krebs did not fight bravely in the war. That he invented lies about his war stories. This had a profound effect on his psych therefore making it difficult for him to live a normal life when he knew the truth all along.
The Term Paper on A Look At Ernest Hemingway’s “Soldier’s Home” Compared To WWI And Shell Shock
World War One (WWI) was arguably the most costly conflict in human history. With over “one third of men returning home” with serious mental ailments, this war had effects long after the armistice treaty (World War I Document Archive 18). This war lasted well past the signing of the treaty and went on to spark the beginning of the Second World War in 1939. Veterans were plagued with ...
In conclusion, both stories were set post war, O’Brien’s over the Nam and his horrors and the impact on the men how they went boys came back men, that perhaps seen more they wanted or care for. Moreover, on Hemmingway’s is the changes and trouble adapting of a young man who before war he had pretty much a normal life just like the rest of his town.
