In comparison to which a preferred more, I would prefer the movie over
the novel. Combining the theatrical elements of Hollywood film noir,
Chandler’s(screen-writer) dialogue skills, and Cain’s hard-boiled style, the
film gives a better insight to the triangular relationship between Phyllis,
Walter, and Keyes.
In the film, we see that Walter is in a never-ending conflict to assert
himself over Phyllis, and at the same time, to become more “intimate” with
Keyes. Through the dialogue’s extensive use of sexual metaphors, we see how
Walter tries to keep Phyllis in check, and bring Keyes closer.
Breaking the traditional film mold of “weak man sucumbing to strong
alluring woman,” Walter is just as cold and hard as Phyllis and thier
relationship, which in my opinion, is not based on lust or greed, but the
image of commiting such an act as partners.It’s a classic scenario to see two
hardened people pull a job together. So we could say that Phyllis and Walter
had a relationship based on one act of violence, with the murder being a
metaphor for a one night stand.
Keyes represented a father figure to Walter, and as the film shows, was
dominant over Neff. The symbolic use of Walter’s infatuation with Keyes
cigar, and the lighting of each other’s cigarette gives us a glimpse of a
... Winkle” and “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” are two very unique and priceless ... post-Revolution while “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty” is set in the roaring ’ ... ? (Thurber 2)” Another large similarity between Walter and Rip are their overwhelming tendencies to avoid any ... James Thurber, a man by the name of Walter Mitty can hardly tell reality from his vivid ...
strange relationship. “I love you” was said to one another in the begining
and the end of the movie. Neff’s relationship with Barton Keyes is similair
to his relations with Phyllis. Rather than exerting himself through notions
and metaphors, Walter tries to extend himself over Keyes by trying to conceal
a perfect crime.
The film’s combination of the noir imagery, hard-boiled dialogue, and
pulp characters gives a better look at the struggle to keep a “perfect”
murder perfect. Cain did a good job iin presenting the story in novel form,
but the material is better presented as a screen-play.