In our society, there are many obstacles that face students who are trying to obtain a college education. First, the student has to do well in high school, pass the S. A. T.’s , and be able to afford to pay for a college education.
For those who can’t afford to pay for college there is Financial Aid. But what if financial aid was taken away from students based solely on one minor drug offense? I will address several reasons why I believe the Souder Amendment is unethical and why it should be repealed. The Souder Amendment was developed by Rep. Mark Souder that denies financial aid to students with a drug conviction. This amendment is in total contradiction of the Higher Education Act which was developed in 1968 to provide financial aid to over 7 million students each year. Financial Aid was invented to provide financial assistance to students who come from low income families.
Seeing how financial aid is solely based on the families financial household income, the money that is awarded to the family should not be in jeopardy if being taken away due to the students prior drug offense. By using this offense as a consequence to committing a drug related crime, it introduces many obstacles for middle class people, 2 minorities, and it ignores the most widely abused drug on college campuses – alcohol. Working class students are the majority of people that attend college on scholarships and financial aid. While in school, experimentation may introduce itself as something that should be done while attending college.
The Term Paper on College Student Aid
Student Aid Is Based on Need not Merit There is no credible evidence that student aid is driving up college tuition rates. Such claims confuse cause and effect. There were no increases in federal student-loan limits, yet tuition steadily climbed. There were no increases in the maximum Pell Grant for four years during the Bush administration, yet tuition continued to increase. The facts are clear: ...
The consequences of allowing yourself to fall victim to drinking or taking drugs previously only had the consequence of a tremendous hang over the next morning. If caught by an official abusing drugs or alcohol, detainment would normally occur and several minor measures would be met to ensure the diversion of attempting to “experiment” again. But now that the Souder Amendment has been drafted, that one offense prevents a student from obtaining anymore government financed money to attend school. This is unethical to me because after the student realizes their mistakes and suffers the embarrassment of getting caught, they now have the burden of trying to obtain money to continue to pay for school. Quickly raising several thousands of dollars to pay for their next semester rarely happens and they are forced to take a semester off of school to save up so they can enroll the following semester. While out of school, the student may be at risk to fall victim to abusing more drugs, seeing how no further measures were taken to provide the 3 student with help while out of school.
Stress and the sense of failure may overcome the students life and the idea of continuing their college education becomes a fading memory. While one experiment with some friends seemed fun while in school, the idea of your entire college career being stripped away from you is a much bigger burden that no student should have to worry about. Minorities make up a very large percentage of college students in the U. S.
Out of that minority, African Americans and Latinos seem to hold onto about 35% combined. As this is already a low percentage, the number will inevitably decrease because of the Souder Amendment due to the fact that minorities are the leading obtainer’s of financial aid. Upper class individuals, usually Caucasian students, are not affected what so ever by this Amendment because they can afford to pay for school on their own. This is unjust because it basically sends a message that its okay to experiment with drugs and get caught as long as you can afford to pay for school on your own. With the number of minorities in college decreasing, minorities high school who are seniors, will become hesitant to attend the majority of Cal States and Universities due to the low percentage of African American and Latino students. The Souder Amendment can be associated with a form of racism because it tends to 4 affect a large number of specific minority groups while the affects of drug abuse and consequence aren’t applied to wealthy students.
The Homework on High School Vs College 2
School is a part of most individual’s life. Each level and every stage has its own differences. The transition between each year in school is different. High school and college, which have similarities and differences, are considered to be the highlight of a student’s life. The transition from high school to college can be very complicated, and they can bring a great challenge and trigger various ...
This amendment does nothing but force minority students to once again feel segregated against and reminded that racism isn’t over. Seeing how this act is supposed to actually help our nations students in the long run, it confuses me only because the Souder supporters chose such a minor offense to discipline criminal offenders. Other than focusing on criminal offenders such as rapist or thieves they have decided to change the fate of most students futures based on whether they have been caught smoking a joint. This seems very unjust to me because alcohol is the leading abused drug on our college campuses. Alcohol abuse has become a vest growing epidemic for several reasons. It is easy accessible to under-age students through the assistance of their 21 year old friends, which allows them to start drinking at a young age.
Also, the idea of drinking at a party is identified as being “cool” or “part of the in crowd” which forces young college students to drink even more than they are accustomed to doing. If caught on a college campuses under the influence of alcohol, the student doesn’t face the risk of not being able to afford school the following semester. Instead, they are given a warning and sent on 5 their way to inevitably abuse alcohol again. There are several Alcohol Abuse Centers that are available to students on campuses, as there are for Drug Abuse Centers, but since the drug offender is more at risk to not being able to continue school, no further effort is made to help the student to stop abusing drugs. It is also unjust to attack such a minor crime seeing how drug abuse is the least abused drug on college campuses today. If anything, I believe the Souder Amendment should b revised and one time drug offenses can be conjoined with alcohol abuse and other drastic crimes to prevent students from obtaining financial aid.
The Term Paper on High School Drug Alcohol Drugs
Sociology High Honors April 11, 2003 How the Use of Drugs and Alcohol Affect High School Achievement student at Lakeside High School, called Ann for purposes of privacy, had a grade point average of 3. 6 through her sophomore year. During her junior year, she dropped out of extra-curricular activities and became withdrawn from other social activities. As she was introduced to the world of hard ...
In conclusion, I believe the Souder Amendment should be repealed, and financial aid should be neglected to those students with actual financial stability and not those who have minor criminal encounters. I totally understand the governments approach to making our schools a more appreciated and respectable place of learning, but I am not promised that the person sitting next to me isn’t a convicted rapist or thief. But with the Souder Amendment in effect at least I know he or she isn’t convicted of smoking pot!
