William Shakespeare is the noted author of a vast array of plays, ranging from comedies to histories to tragedies. Perhaps one of his most famous in the tragedy genre is Macbeth. Though Shakespeare can be considered as a scholar in the sense that he was both a renowned and prolific playwright, look back a few hundred years to find Aristotle, one of the most famous scholars and philosophers of all time. In his treatise titled Poetics, he defends poetry against criticism as well as sets standards for tragedies in “The Nature of Tragedy,” a section of the Poetics. Is Macbeth fit to be included in the tragedy genre according to the standards set by Aristotle? According to Aristotle, a tragedy is “an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude.” It also should “excite pity or fear” in the spectator. An important concept of tragedy is that of “katharsis” or “purgation”.
By that, Aristotle means that the spectators feel for the characters onstage, and in doing so, undergoes a so-called “cleansing of the soul.” Though the concept of katharsis is increasingly important in the play, there are six specific elements that make up a tragedy; without them, there would be no play and no katharsis. Of the six, which include plot, character, thought, diction, song, and spectacle, the first two are the most important. The most important aspect of tragedy is the plot, which is considered to be “the soul of a tragedy.” The plot of Macbeth is complex, meaning that it contains Recognition and Reversal of the Situation. Macbeth believes that every man is of woman born, and thus he cannot be killed by anyone. “Thou losest labor./ As easy mayest thou the intrenchant air/ With thy keen sword impress as make me bleed./ Let fall thy blade on vulnerable crests./ I bear a charmed life, which must not yield/ To one of woman born.” This is a scene that contains Recognition; it is when Macbeth realizes that another of the witches’ prophecies are coming true as well as the fact that he has to yield. Once Macbeth establishes himself to be invincible, Macduff tells him that he is not of woman born. “Despair thy charm!/ And let the angel whom thou still hast served/ Tell thee Macduff was from his mother’s womb/ Untimely ripped.” In a way, there is also a Reversal of the Situation in that particular action.
The Essay on What Makes a Good Tragedy According to Aristotle
Oedipus fulfills the function of a tragedy, and arouses fear and pity in the highest degree. But unfortunately a modern reader, coming to the classic drama not entirely for the purpose of enjoyment, will not always surrender himself to the emotional effect. He is correct to worry about Greek fatalism and the justice of the downfall of Oedipus, and, finding no satisfactory solution for these ...
Macbeth enters the situation beliving that he will triumph over Macduff, but by Macduff revealing his true birth, he produces the opposite effect. Now Macbeth has to accept that fact that he will yield, and in doing so, dies. Another part of the plot is the Scene of Suffering, which is “a destructive or painful action.” In the case of Macbeth, the Scene of Suffering could be the bloody murder of Duncan by Macbeth. As stated in “The Nature of Tragedy,” the change in fortune should be from good to bad rather than from bad to good. Although the sequence of events that occur throughout Macbeth may not appear to document a change in fortune from good to bad, they all constitute of a change because it shows Macbeth’s moral downfall. Also, according to Aristotle, the misfortune should be brought by the character’s own error or frailty.
In the case of Macbeth, the frailty that brings about his misfortune and eventual destruction is ultimately ambition. Another important aspect of a tragedy is character. In his Poetics, Aristotle says that “first and most important, it must be good.” Macbeth’s character in Macbeth is not exactly the portrayal of an ideal man, but he is not the worst man either. He may appear to be wicked and corrupt throughout the play, but he is actually portrayed as a relatively good man in the beginning of the play. At the start of the play, he possesses valor and bravery in the war and Duncan considers him to be honorable. “What he hath lost noble Macbeth hath won.” The second thing is propriety. In a way, Lady Macbeth’s character can be deemed inappropriate because she possesses more strength than Macbeth, as well as the fact that she is amazingly clever.
The Essay on Macbeth As A Tragedy According To Aristotles Definition
While the genre of some works of literature can be debated, Macbeth written by William Shakespeare seems to fit into a perfect mold. Aristotles definition of a tragedy, combining seven elements that he believes make the genre of a work a tragedy, is that mold. Displaying all seven aspects, Macbeth fits the definition precisely. Key elements in the play substantiate the fact that Macbeth is a ...
She is able to manipulate Macbeth into murdering Duncan; he has his fears, but Lady Macbeth is the one that sways him to his decision. “From this time/ Should I account thy love. Art thou afeard/ To be the same in thine own act and valor/ As thou art in desire? Wouldst thou have that/ Which thou estemm’st the ornament of life,/ And live a coward in thine own esteem,/ Letting ‘I dare not’ wait upon the ‘I would,’/ Like the poor cat i’ the adage?” The third thing is that the character must be true to life. In Macbeth, both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are considerably true to life. Some of the events that occur in this play has also occurred in history. Like Macbeth, was Julius Caesar not murdered as the ultimate result of ambition? What it comes down to is that Lady Macbeth only wants what is best for her and her husband, and that “best” is for him to become king and for her to be queen. The fourth and last point is consistency. Both are consistently egotistic in the sense that nothing stands in the way of what they want.
In one scene, Macbeth says, “For mine own good,/ All causes shall give way…” Also, Lady Macbeth is consistently repressing her conscience (until it leads to her suicide) in order for her to feel indifferent to the crimes that she has to plot. “Make thick my blood;/ Stop up the access and passage to remorse…” The concept of character in terms of Aristotle’s “perfect tragedy” is different than that of the above. In an ideal tragedy, the character portrayed should be neither extremely bad nor extremely good; instead, he should be in-between extremes. In actuality, Macbeth can be described as being in-between the two extremes because of his generally good nature in the beginning of the play. Macbeth is also not extremely bad; although that may appear to be true, he is not an apathetic mass murderer. He has an internal conflict, and one part of that conflict is the fact that his conscience is not silenced at all. Most of the time, the only reason why he continues with his evil deeds is because it is too late for him to turn back.
The Essay on Macbeth Tragedy
ter> According to the classical view, tragedy should arouse feelings of pity and fear in the audience. Does macbeth do this? Shakespeares Macbeth is definitely a tragedy in the sense that it arouses feelings of pity and fear in the audience. Macbeth is a weak minded man who, if sees an opportunity for power follows his ambitions and takes it, even if this is not the rightful thing to do. He is ...
“For mine own good/ All causes shall give way. I am in blood/ Stepped so far that, should I wade no more,/ Returning were as tedious as go o’er.” The character in a perfect tragedy should also be of high status. That is true of Macbeth throughout the length of the play; his status never really drops because he ascends from being Thane of Glamis to Thane of Cawdor and finally, to King of Scotland. In most, if not all respects of plot and character, Macbeth fits Aristotle’s standards of a tragedy. It is the dark undertone found throughout Macbeth that makes it the tragedy that it is noted to be; though it does not yet have the “Hollywood status” like Romeo and Juliet, there is no doubt that it has the capability to attain that status. It is considered to be a tragedy by today’s standards as well as the standards of classical Greece..
