Compare and Contrast absolute and relative approaches to the definition and measurement of poverty The term Poverty has many definitions all of which share similar ideas, It is often defined as a state of deprivation relative to those standards of living enjoyed by others within the same society. Terms used to describe poverty may include; Income or consumption poverty, Human under development, Social exclusion, Ill being, Vulnerability, lack of basic needs and relative deprivation. All of the terms mentioned above are regularly used to describe what is meant by poverty. Townsend quotes that; Individuals, families and groups in the population can be said to be in poverty when they lack the resources to obtain the types of diet, participate in the activities and have the living conditions and amenities which are customary, or at least widely encouraged or approved, in the societies to which they belong. Their resources are so seriously below those commanded by the average individual or family that they are, in effect, excluded from ordinary living patterns, customs and activities. Poverty has been considered throughout history.
Rowntree study, published in 1901, was the first to create a poverty standard for individual families, based on estimates of nutritional and other requirements. Concepts of poverty have developed rapidly however there are fault lines in the debates of poverty and what is actually meant by poverty. The complexity of the measurement of poverty mirrors the complexity of its definition. absolute poverty is the idea that it is possible to create an absolute minimum standard of living required for physical health, this is often called the poverty line. This definition of poverty is most often used by international and global organisations such a the United Nations. Such a definition has been criticised by sociologists as they argue that it is a very general and global definition and therefore fails to take into account important socio-economic differences between countries and nations.
The Essay on Composite Indicators of Poverty and Living Standards:
Development is more than simply increasing economic output i.e.GDP per capita. It is a wider concept than economic growth. Even if a country's economy experiences real growth of GDP it does not mean that economic development is taking place. Nevertheless, wider more meaningful indicators of development are often correlated with GDP per capita.The Physical Quality of Life Index (PQLI)In this index ...
In 1901 Rowntree created this idea that there is a minimum standard or a minimum necessary to maintain mere physical health. The idea was intended to demolish the view that poverty was due to fecklessness. This measurement usually involves judgement of basic human needs and resources essential for health. In 1899 Rowntree created the poverty line based on dietary which was intended to provide a family with adequate nutrition at a minimum cost. The families whose income was too low to provide the minimum necessities were considered to be in primary poverty. If the family were able to budget efficiently then they may be considered to be in secondary poverty.
The application of the subsistence approach has implications for social policy. If society is able to provide a sufficient income to meet subsistence needs then poverty can be abolished. Rowntree purposely left out consideration of needful for the development of mental, moral and social sides of human nature. In later work Rowntree did attempt to incorporate the social factors. The concept of relative poverty has mainly replaced that of absolute poverty in sociological research. Relative poverty is measured in terms of judgements by members of a particular society of what is considered a reasonable and acceptable standard of living.
Townsend’s definition is based on the assumptions that poverty can only be defined and understood within the broader socio-economic context of the society in which individuals live, relative poverty measures whether or not a person is poor in relation to those around them. This definition of poverty suggests that the poor in any given society are in part defined by their opposite, the rich. A society has a distinctive set of cultural norms and values any definition of poverty must include the choices and expectations that individuals have in their society. Any poverty line must be drawn relative to given societies and further to the social divisions they are in. Within the idea of relative poverty the measurement of poverty is not concerned with the scientific calculation of a minimum income needed for physical survival, but with the income necessary to participate in the wide range of roles and relationships that constitute full membership of society. Implications of this idea are that the standards change over time therefore poverty is harder to eradicate.
The Essay on Poverty In Australia Line Income Henderson
Poverty In Australia Before discussing the extent of poverty in Australia, it is first crucial to mention the difference between absolute poverty and relative poverty. Absolute Poverty is a situation where deprivation is extreme because people do not have access to the basic necessities such as food, clothing, and shelter. In contrast Relative Poverty is a situation in which the incidence of ...
It involves acceptance of a particular view of the causes of poverty. Income poverty means that you are considered poor if you have less money than the defined poverty line for your country. Measuring poverty is always considered a major problem in the poverty debate. Money is not the only way in which poverty is measured other factors must be considered to create a fair measurement. Human poverty takes into account many other aspects apart from money such as life expectancy, infant malnutrition, illiteracy and lack of clean water and food. Basic needs definitions also go beyond money including all the things a person needs to survive including employment and participation in society.
The Rowntree Trust/ New policy Institute uses fifty indicators to measure poverty in Britain. There are a number of new ways of measuring poverty such as the Index of Sustainable Economic Welfare. This measures quality economic activity. Another method is the Human Poverty Index, this is ranked according to three main areas of deprivation: survival, knowledge and a decent standard of living. The Gender Related Developmental Index is a measure of female poverty and development across a number of variables.
The Term Paper on Poverty in the United States and Different Poverty Measure
... Human Poverty Index (HPI) and ranks 78 poor countries using it. The report asserts that poverty is multidimensional, and poverty measures ... for inflation using Consumer Price Index (CPI-U). The official poverty definition uses money income before taxes and does ... and food stamps). Income used to compute poverty status: Money income Includes earnings, unemployment compensation, workers’ compensation, ...
Conceptions of poverty are held by individuals and groups and these are institutionalised by the state. A large amount of individuals believe that poverty is a standard of living below a minimally defined level. Geller wrote that poverty is an essentially contested concept. Poverty has many meanings and because of this definitions, measurement and explanations of poverty have much controversy and debate within the sociological analysis.
