Rhetorical Situation Analysis Same sex marriage is considered to be one of the most controversial and debated issue during the last two decades, extending its polemics beyond from societal to political level. The majority of gay and lesbian communities fight for same sex marriage arguing on the basis of their civil rights and ones of heterosexual couples. However, on the other hand same sex marriage is considered as a social deviation from middle class issues, and thus contradictive to just like everyone else conservatism. Moreover, some homosexual communities allege that it would be more important to accomplish domestic partnership rights for everyone and thus annul the unjust and obsolete institution of marriage (Cox, 273).
Speech performed by Frank Rogers Same Sex and the Idea of Equality, initially delivered at Fortnightly Club, is a reflection on the US Presidents State of the Union speech, in particular that part of it regarding same sex marriage. Moreover, the speech contains specific discussion of contemporary dilemma in terms of freedom of individuals choice and the idea of equality in society.
Addressing from the very beginning to the core of the problem, Rogers intentionally avoids possible pitfalls in terms of legal prospective of same sex marriage, and concentrates on the idea of family as a societal institution, which limits individuals freedom. According to Rogers one thing is clear in dealing with the conception of marriage right up to the past few centuries, is that marriage was for the States benefit, to encourage procreation, enhance the comfort and the physical pleasure of the male only. Rogers thesis makes sense especially in regard to past social trends around same sex marriage. Being inspired by the activism in the 1960s that secured political and economic rights for blacks and women, American gays and lesbians mobilized to end what they viewed as the discriminatory practice of granting marriage licenses only to heterosexual couples. As law professor William N. Eskridge Jr.
The Term Paper on Gay Marriage Sex People Society
The legalization of gay marriage is a topic that has been argued in our society for several years. This is also a theme that most people oppose because it is very hard to accept same sex marriage between couples. There are several debates without outcomes we have had over the past several years to seek the right for gay people to marry because it is very difficult to throw away all what that is ...
has stated in his book, The Case for Same-Sex Marriage, Marriage is the most important right the state has to offer, in part because being married entails dozens of associated rights, benefits, and obligations under state and federal law (Eskridge, 21).
These pertain to such matters as parenthood, property ownership, guardianship, and inheritance. Although Eskridge cites anthropological and ethnographic evidence of same sex unions throughout history, the modern movement to legitimize same sex marriage provoked a profound public and political reaction. To date, more than half the states in the United States have passed statutes that either have defined marriage as the union of one man and one woman or have explicitly declared same sex marriages to be illegal, whether performed in or out of state. From the critical point of view, examination of central part of Rogers speech reveals that he utilizes philosophical evaluation of the dilemma, both classic and contemporary. It can be considered to be an important factor for skeptical as well as acknowledged audience. In order to present some empirical evidence for the expression of his ideas, Rogers points out evidences derived from the ancient Greek, classical French and German philosophy , and the Bible and cooperates them with contemporary scientific trends and opinions regarding individuals sexual orientation.
Thus, Rogers masterfully manoeuvres in the diversity of the audiences points of view. Simultaneously, summarizing the speech and emphasizing his main idea, Rogers indicates that same sex marriage as well as homosexuality should not be considered to be a merely sexual perversion. The whole dilemma should be recognized and comprehended in terms of contemporary society, psychology and science. Rogers affirms that that democratic institutions in the West have shown that true progress must ultimately rest on a spiritual will and that a religious revival can be almost synonymous with enlightened citizenship. From the critical point of view, Rogers proposed combination of the church and civil society regarding resolution of the same sex marriage issue represents an extremely doubtful outcome. In addition, from the practical point of view, it is even not necessary to aim for such dangerous union, because the churchs attitude towards the issue has always been consistent and significantly grounded on the Bible and doctrines of the church. Rogers indicates that the fundamental human right to marriage should not be ignored or denied.
The Essay on Marriage Sex Man Woman
Marriage is legally defined and summed up as, a contract made in due form of law, by which a free man and a free woman reciprocally engage to live with each other during their joint lives, in the union which ought to exist between husband and wife. Many liberals argue that gay marriage should be legal in the United States. In the following essay I will attempt to argue why marriage between the ...
His thesis obtains even more value in contemporary political and contemporary context. According to Rogers idea, the modern marriage does not exist solely for reproductive purposes, contemporary judicial system and legislatures aim to oppose. There are still various ways to maintain the institution of marriage, family and parenthood. parenthood could be achieved by same-sex couples through the use of a surrogate mother, in gay marriage, the artificial insemination of one or both females, in lesbian marriage, as well as adoption. The validation of same sex marriage would have the effect of increasing the occurrence and popularity of all three procedures. Many homosexual couples will look upon the prospect of marriage as an enduring affirmation of their mutual commitment and love.
On the other hand, many members of the gay and lesbian community view marriage not as an opportunity they have long been unjustly denied but as an inducement to abandon their creative countercultural lifestyle in exchange for membership in the dull and monogamous conformity of mainstream society. The legalization of same sex marriages could set a precedent for other, even more radical unions. Though these may seem like low-probability scenarios, they offer futurists a useful exercise in exploring the potential implications of a radical trajectory (Lee, 174).
The appearance of marriage between same sex couples indicated one of the major cultural and social changes of the twentieth century not only in the United States, but across the globe. In speech Same Sex and the Idea of Equality, Frank Rogers revealed important idea of same sex unions in the contemporary society in terms of individual choice and historical implications. In order to disclose the whole exigency of dilemma resolution, Rogers indicated important philosophical empirical evidence. Although the speaker presented important notions regarding the problem, Rogers abandoned some important practical context, in particular legal issues around marriage definition in courts, which might sharpen the general flow of the speech. Within the lesbian and gay communities and the heterosexual societies, the heated dilemma as to what constitutes marriage continues to sharpen, and actually depends on the moral majoritys opinion.
The Essay on Lust And Lutyens Marriage Sex House
Lust and Lutyens The Architect and his Wife: A Life of Edwin Lutyens Jane RidleyChatto and Wind us 25, pp 488 Jane Ridley does not quite blame the sexual incompatibility of her great-grandparents, Edwin and Emily Lutyens, for the tower blocks of the 1960 s, but it's tempting to cut and paste her narrative a little to come up with a pretty startling new interpretation of the course of British ...
Bibliography Eskridge W. N. Jr. The Case for Same-Sex Marriage, Boston Books, 1999 Lee P., George, R. What Sex Can Be: Self- Alienation, Illusion, or One-Flesh Union American Journal of Jurisprudence, 42:1997 Cox B. The Little Project: From Alternative Families to Domestic Partnerships to Same-Sex Marriage.
Wisconsin Womens Law Journal, 15:2000 Rogers F. Same Sex and the Idea of Equality. Vital Speeches of the Day.NY: 70(10),2004 http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?RQT=309&VInst=PROD& VName=PQD&VType=PQD&sid=1&index=0&SrchMode=1&Fmt=3 &did=000000601494941&clientId=35492.
