What is a good doctor? What makes a good doctor perfect? In the articles “Phlebitis” by Lair Eigther,”The Doctors as Stranger” by David Rothman, and the book “The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down” by Anne Fadiman these authors state different situations and outlooks the patients were in. For instance the writers explored whether the patients had good medical treatment. Furthermore the authors view the disconnection between the doctors and the patients on how physicians should be able to train differently so we can enrich the relationship between the doctor and patient. Patients believe a good doctor is a doctor that is compassionate. A good doctor is a doctor who communicates with their patient, gives medical information and understands the culture, beliefs and the situation of the patient. For example my niece Gabriela De La Rosa was born without an ear, so her doctor was going to construct her left ear.
My aunt doesn’t speak English just Spanish, my aunt had a hard time communicating with the physician. She came to my house a day before the surgery to ask me if I could help her translate, I gladly said yes. In Loma Linda Hospital her surgery was taken at eleven in the morning her doctor and nurses were ready for the surgery. Her doctor kept in touch with me every thirty minutes. The doctor gave us information about any complication, on every step they were doing. He kept in contact for the six hours my niece was in surgery. My niece’s doctor understood our culture because he was also Hispanic he knew that my aunt was passing thru a difficult time and understood her. After the surgery the doctor was checking on my niece at least 3 times a day. He was communicating with us and telling us how fast she was progressing and how she can go home tomorrow in the afternoon and she kept up the good work. This is a good doctor.
The Essay on A Country Doctor Boy Patient Rose
Franz Kafka's 'The Country Doctor " Commentary by behnamKafka's story 'The Country Doctor' is one of his most enigmatic, because it is one of his most symbolic, and his symbols defy easy explanation. The story opens with a kindly physician standing outside his home in 'great perplexity'; his horse has died, and he has been summoned to see a critically-ill patient some ten miles away. The doctor's ...
A doctor that is doing his job on helping his patient’s in need. Additionally in the book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down Anne Fadiman writes about Lia who had good doctors and she was still suffering with her health. Fadiman forces us to question what makes a “perfect” doctor. A good physician is not a perfect one for example in the book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down Dr. Bill explain that the Dr. Neil is not a perfect physician “If Neil made a mistake, it’s because every physician makes mistakes. If it had been a brand new kid walking off the street, I guarantee you Neil would have done a septic work up and he would have caught it. But this was Lia . No one at Merced Community Medical Center would have notice anything but her seizures. Lia was her seizures”(Fadiman 256).
The quote explains that if Dr. Neil was dealing with any other child off the street he would have done an extraordinary job and wouldn’t have a difficult time with the patient is health, and understanding the culture and language. What is a bad physician? A bad doctor is one who views the patient as a profit but not a human. Therefore author Rothman states on his article that many doctors view the patients as profit not human beings that need medical help. For example “The Doctor Business , tell about an accident in which a young boy fell into a well ; after volunteers worked unstintingly for twenty four hours to dig him out, his parents took him to a local doctor, who proceeded to bill $1500 for his services” (Rothman 141).
What Rothman explains that No physician has the right to refuse health care to anybody if they are not stable financially.
Every patient has the right to have health care in any clinic, hospital, and emergency room. Another way of proving that a doctor is a bad doctor is by giving his patient the medication he believes it’s better for the patient. A doctor that believes on giving him the medication he believes is better for its patient. When the patient knows that the medication that was given to him was not helping his pain. For example referring back to Eightner article he states this “I asked that the Vicodin be changed to Naprosyn another nonsteroid pain reliever and anti-inflammatory drug comparable in effect to Ibuprofen. Eventually a nurse brought me some Ibuprofen. Perhaps if I had asked for ibuprofen I would have got Naprosyn” (Eighner 151).
The Term Paper on Doctors Listening Skills Patients Patient Medical
Doctors' Listening Skills When people go to the doctor's office they want the doctor to listen. Competency and a correct diagnosis are appreciated too, but more than anything, patients value doctors's i lence (Richards, 1407). In addition, patients want "more and better information about their problem and the outcome, more openness about the side effects of treatment, relief of pain and emotional ...
Eighner asked for certain medication to help him out on his pain but the faculty believes on giving him the medication they consider is better for his medical help he states if he would of asked for another medication he would of got the medication he need .
What is the patient’s bill of rights? Many Patients don’t know what their rights are. Everyone has the right to health care in any clinic, hospital and emergency room the bill of rights form should be given to the patients so they could know and understand what their rights are. Eighner was one of the few patients that knew what his bills of rights were, but also had some knowledge of medication. Eighner was a patient that only had a watery swelling ankle that needed medical attention. Eightner’s rights were violated by the faculty and doctors. Eighner was not allowed to view his medical chart, and he was given different medication. Doctors had lied to him about his medical condition. They also stated that if he left the hospital he was not going to survive because he had a deadly medical condition.
Eigther realize the doctors were lying to him because the physician didn’t allow him to view his medical chart. For example Eighther remembered pointing out to Dr. Stalin when Dr. Velasquez said he could view his chart whenever he wanted. “I pointed out that he had been in the room when Dr. Stalin had said I could look at the chart whenever I wanted. He claims he had been called out of the room and had not heard her say that. Of course he had not been called out of the room. I knew for a fact he was there” (Eightner 153).
Eightner rights were violated and his doctors were bad doctors because they lied about his medical condition. He was one of a kind patient that knew his bill of rights and notice on time that the doctors were lying to him . How can we change doctors training system? Society believes that doctors training system need to change because of the miscommunication with the patients and their culture.
The Essay on Assisted Suicide Physician Patient Medication
Assisted Suicide In 1997, Oregon became the only state allowing legal physician-assisted suicide (PAS). Although physician-assisted suicide has been legal in Oregon for four years, it remains highly controversial. PAS is when a doctor prescribes their patient to medication which would kill them. Patients must pass certain requirements in order to request a prescription for lethal medication. The ...
Fadiman doctors have misunderstanding of the Hmong culture. The book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down has several conflicts doctors vs. parents, parent vs. doctors, doctors vs. Doctors, miscommunication with each other. Physician had conflicts with Lia’s parents because of their culture, language and belief’s. “Merced Community Medical Hospital had not yet hired any interpreters, de jure or de facto, for any shift. At that time the only employee who sometimes translated for the Hmong patients was a janitor, a Laotian immigrant fluent in his own language, Laos which few Hmong understand; halting in Hmong; and even more halting in English. (Fadiman 25-26).
This quote means that Merced Community Medical Hospital had not hired an interpreter to help doctors communicate with Lia’s Parent and the only person that would help them communicate would be there janitor. Additionally Fadiman had seen the conflict between doctors vs. parents, when Lia’s doctor tried to apply a medication to her but her parents refused.
The doctors called child services because they believed that Lia was safer in a foster home because they need to give her the right amount of medication, her patents were giving her too much or too little of it; it was never the right amount because of the misunderstanding of the language. For example “Lia’s prescriptions had been changed so often, her parents might been more likely to give her, her medication since they would have been less confused and more confident that the doctors knew what they were doing (Fadiman 78).Lia’s parents had a difficult time giving her the medication because and Lias prescription was changed of often, he parents were most likely given her to much or too little of it. Parents vs. Doctors were having a difficult time because the parent thought the doctors were harmful. The Hmong’s fear doctors because they believe American Doctors would eat them after their dead. “When Hmong people die in the United States, is it true that they cut into pieces and put it in tin cans and sold as food” (Fadiman 32).
The Term Paper on Philosophy Of Medicine Lias Hmong Western
... medicine were given.From the doctors perspective it was all they could do at the time (Fadiman 97) ). Lias parents believed that the ... faith in the healing power of their medicine.Before Lia became severely ill, Hmong did not entirely dismiss Western medicine. They did, ... some greater "good.(Blais 93) " The difficulty in deciding what good and obligation are has led moral philosophers to divide into ...
The Hmong culture believed that American doctors cut them and sold their bodies in food cans after they were dead. The doctors vs. doctors were arguing that one was better than the other. “Later on when I figured out what had happen, or not happened on the earlier visits to the ER, I felt good. It’s kind of a thrill to find something someone else missed, especially when you a resident and you are looking for excuse to make yourself feel smarter than the other physicians”(Fadiman 27,28).
Meaning one of the doctors that helped Lia before in the ER didn’t pay attention to Lia’s symptoms and bragging that you’re a great doctor in MCMC but Dr.Murphy diagnose her with epilepsy.Dr. Dan Murphy diagnose Lia’s seizures. Lia parents already know how to diagnose their daughter problem. They believe it was her spirit catches you and you fall down.
Lia’s parents never knew that Dr. Dan had diagnosed Lia with epilepsy. Dr. Dan would have been surprised to hear they were caused by soul loss. What makes a good doctor good? One can conclude that even a good doctor can make mistakes and there is no perfect doctor even if it’s good or bad. All doctors have different way of doing their medical job. Every patient needs to know their rights so Doctors won’t violate their right just like Eighner. Eighner is one of the few patients that knew his bill of right. How society wants to change the doctors training system so they could understand other cultures and be connected with its patients.
