The Long and Winding Road: How Jails Came to Be in America [The guards here believe that] the tougher, colder, and more cruel and inhuman a place is, the less chance a person will return. This is not true. The more negative experiences a person goes through, the more he turns into a violent, cruel, mean, heartless individual, I know this to be a fact- Anonymous Prisoner, “The Trauma of Prison Rape” (Manner 130) The prisoner described the truth of jails as he is experiencing them now, while the original Quaker intentions had something much different in mind. The Quakers, who were led under William Penn, were the first group to set up an institutionalized system in the United States that dealt with punishment. Since the original plans were developed for the prison system, the goal and intentions have been reformed time and time again.
Although jails are supposed to be a place of rehabilitation, the reality is that they are actually a hotbed for spurring criminals more violent then when they were first admitted. Before jails were even implemented in America, the colonists had quite a different approach to punishment that led to how jails came to be. The original outlook of criminals came from the Colonists religious belief that criminals were sinners who were workers of the devil. The Colonists felt they had to be protected from devil’s workforce and therefore criminals must have their name run into the ground, be cast out of the town, or in the most extreme cases be hung. Before the Colonists accepted institutions, they looked to public humiliation as a means of correcting the lesser criminals. The harsher punishments, such as death, were given to people who were believed to be beyond redemption.
The Term Paper on Crime and Punishment 13
Crime and Punishment The issue of crime and punishment has been a cornerstone for many people of different time periods. There is no doubt that each and every crime should have corresponding and justified outcome for the person committed it in a form of punishment. Although society has to identify what is the crime and what are the reasons and outcomes of the action of an individual to ...
But, with growing populations due to industrialization of cities townspeople grew less and less known to one another. With less recognition between citizens the thought of public humiliation as a punishment was weakening as a threat. On top of that, people were beginning to grow weary that capital punishment may have been too barbaric and overall ineffective. Yet, the colonists were still not completely convinced to utilize jails. The hesitation was a result of the community feeling that most men were not salvageable and institutionalizing them would only be rewarding. Although, this conception began to unravel in the late 1600’s when the Pennsylvania Quakers came up with a plan that would eventually be accepted.
William Penn was rumored to have based his correctional model after the prison facility Bridewell that was located near London. Regardless of whether he replicated or not, he was still part of the first group to suggest using correctional facilities for punishment regarding larger crimes. The Quakers began using this system in Pennsylvania and West Jersey for all serious crimes except for 1 st degree murder. But, the rules set forth by William Penn began to change after he was removed from power and his great law was replaced by Anglican code. Colonists preferred to take on harsher penal sanctions (Clare 38).
But it was during the years of 1790 to 1830 that the population shift took too much of a toll on the Colonists.
As the Colonists struggled to maintain a model code of punishment, the emergence of Italian mathematician and legal scholar Cas are Beccaria came to really influence the Colonists conception of punishment. As a result of Beccaria’s insights, convinced Americans were more then ready to apply his theories. Beccaria had written an essay titled “On Crimes and Punishments” that challenged many to forgo their barbaric approaches of punishment. Beccaria emphasized the point that a potential offender would refrain from engaging in criminal activity if he believed the possibility of getting caught existed. He considered the most important aspect of crime prevention to be the certainty of punishment. Although, he stressed heavily the fact that incredibly harsh punishment only makes matters worse because it brutalizes the individual causing him to become even more involved in crime.
The Essay on Control And Punishment Crime Prison Problems
Better Alternatives Other Than Control and Punishment Society has other alternatives to decreasing crime than simply locking people in prison. Preventative programs focus on the community, school, family, employment and places. In addition, there are rehabilitation and restorative justice programs that can also be used to decrease crime. Prisons are the only alternatives we hear about from ...
Beccaria even suggested that those governments that impose the harshest punishments are in fact the same places, which are experiencing the worst acts of crime (Clare 39).
In 1790, Americans put Beccaria’s words into action when a majority of the states either abolished the death penalty completely or significantly decreased its usage. During the same time period the Colonists wanted to make state prisons and looked to European models for influence. After the completion of the first few state models, the trend of infiltrating rehabilitation programs in prisons came forth. The general rehabilitation models for prisons have gone through many phases. In the beginning, “the Custodial Model” was the most adherent and derived from the Quakers outlook on humanitarianism as means of reforming.
The notion was that if the criminal were kept in complete solitude then contemplation on their bad deeds would ensue. There was absolutely no integration between inmates. In the mid nineteenth century the model began to change again with the emergence of both probation and parole programs. Although these practices took almost a century to really evolve, a new mentality towards the field of corrections was born. The application of medicine as a means to cure prisoners of their mental illnesses became fervent. At this time many programs were introduced that are still present today such as Alcoholics Anonymous.
Yet, some argued that this approach was teaching prisoners that they are not at fault for the crimes committed but rather their illness is. Critics felt that this idealism shifted the blame off the offender who ideally is in jail contemplating his mistakes for his criminal activities. The feelings that the current prisons at the time were not fit for rehabilitation treatments lead to a new era of corrections. It became more known over time that crime tends to come from people who are adrift from their community. Therefore people, who are more integrated into society, have community and family ties, are more likely to conform and not commit crimes.
The Term Paper on Can Prison Deter Crime?
“Danbury wasn’t a prison, it was a crime school. I went in with a Bachelor of marijuana, came out with a Doctorate of cocaine” – George Jung The above quote was given by notorious international drug lord, and one of the most successful career criminal of modern times, George Jung, when discussing the flaws of the modern penal system. While subsequent to this original incarceration, ...
This relatively newly popularized thought brought out the next and most current phase. The new state of mind emphasized community based corrections. Parole and Probation officers became much more common as well as the building of state of the art correction facilities and halfway houses (Carney 95).
Correction facilities today are a combination of the many phases of the past. Although Prisons due integrate community based initiatives they are done so selectively, which means not every offender has the equal opportunity to take part in rehabilitative programs.
Life in prison today is not fulfilling the humanitarian goals that were embedded in the original lay out set forth by the Quakers, that goal being of prisoner contemplation through solitude. Prisoners now must go through a rigorous day of activities beginning at the crack of dawn while getting paid close to nothing, eating non-nutritional meals, and enduring harassment so horrific in some cases that using bathrooms is completely out of the question. Jails have also run into the problem of over population that has led to doubling up on cells. With all these factors moving against the prisoner it is no wonder they leave more messed up then when they arrived.
As the prisoner stated in the opening quote, the strategy set forth by prison officials highly contrasts with what could actually change a person. The overall object of the field of corrections defies most of the underlying work it should be based upon. Another blatant example of present days ignorance of past principles occurs in the case of Beccaria. And influence on depleting the use of harsher punishment. Since the days when his ideas were prevalent a number of states are still using capital punishment and practically frivolously at that. The different ways of treatment may have changed in the past, but the common goal of reintegration never did.
Today, there is a mixed message being sent to the citizens of America. One emphasizes that people who commit crimes should be rehabilitated and sent back into society as a conformed individual, while the truth on the insides of jails tends to paint a very different picture. At the same time people are supposed to believe that all offenders can be salvaged, yet the death penalty is still being imposed in much of America. Crime rates are growing more rapidly every year and clearly reformation needs to take place once again. Certain aspects such as mandatory sentencing that contradict rehabilitation procedures should be done away with.
The Essay on Carandiru Movie Overview One Prisoners Prison
Carandiru The adaptation of Carandiru Station, a best-seller by Drauzio Varela, Carandiru proposes diving into the heart of S~ao Paulo's prison, the largest in Latin America with approximately 7, 000 prisoners with a capacity for 4, 500. Guided by a humanist doctor (the author) who has an affection for the prisoners, the audience shares in the daily life of the condemned before the massacre ...
Prisons should also look back to the earlier model of disintegrating prisoners from each other, and instead slowly re-introduce the prisoner to the positive aspects of the community he left behind such as family. A greater emphasis needs to be put on the humanitarianism aspect that the Quakers stressed so long ago. Only with the care and deliberation of the Quaker school of thought combined with Beccaria’s influence will the crime rates lower and the ultimate goal of rehabilitation through prison begin to be realized.
